Never Wanted To Be That Girl - Live From Music City - Carly Pearce Share: Download MP3 More song by Carly Pearce I Hope You’re Happy Now 3:18 Never Wanted To Be That Girl 3:34 You Kissed Me First 3:16 Easy Going 4:46 Should’ve Known Better 3:01 What He Didn't Do 3:11 Next Girl 2:44 Diamondback - Commentary 0:31 Should’ve Known Better 3:01 Diamondback 3:02 29 3:43 What He Didn’t Do - Commentary 0:35 Next Girl 2:44 Liability 2:44 What He Didn't Do 3:11 Messy 2:53 Easy Going - Commentary 0:30 Show Me Around 3:40 Easy Going 4:46 Day One 3:30