Why Shouldn't We - Mary Chapin Carpenter Share: Download MP3 More song by Mary Chapin Carpenter Thanksgiving Song 2:48 Christmas Carol 5:09 Once In Royal David's City 3:21 Hot Buttered Rum 3:26 Still, Still, Still 3:25 On A Quiet Christmas Morn 3:49 Come Darkness, Come Light 3:58 Candlelight Carol 3:57 The Calling 4:17 We're All Right 3:48 Twilight 4:31 It Must Have Happened 4:01 Your Life Story 4:21 Houston 5:46 Leaving Song 4:01 On With The Song 3:55 Here I Am 4:18 Bright Morning Star 4:53 Christmas Time In The City 3:21